Skip to main content

War, Borders, and Making the State Look Real


This brief comment was part of my introduction to the Old Mole Variety Hour on July 2, 2018. It is part of my ongoing mission as an Old Mole to make capitalism look as bad as it really is, a task made necessary by capitalism’s never-ending capacity to appear neutral or even benign.
Capitalism depends on the nation-state for many things, including organizing and defending its way of doing business in the world. Thus the State regulates and limits the ability of workers to organize to minimize their exploitation; it funnels profits to major corporations for the production of war and security materiel and for building and operating camps and prisons for the enemies of the state. The nation-state, of course, is only a social fiction, and yet it must command the loyalty and even the veneration of most of its people since it is in the holy name of the Nation that people are often required to lay down their lives on the battlefield for its preservation and honor. And it is precisely the mountains of the dead left on battlefields that makes the state real and revered by its people. We are encouraged to believe, as the Roman poet Horace put it, that “It is sweet and proper to die for the fatherland,” or, as we now say, the Homeland, and that so many have died for it makes us believe that it must be real – since we are not allowed to say that all those soldiers died for an illusion. Another way the State can make itself seem real in the eyes of its people is by making a spectacular defense of its borders against people it demonizes as outsiders, enemies, alien people. That of course is what’s happening on our Southern border today: The nation state that calls itself “America,” and that has historically conceived of itself as “White”, is trying to make itself “Great” by militarizing the arbitrary line between itself and the peoples of other American nations.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

MEANINGLESSNESS AND DESPAIR

In Woody Allen’s film “Crimes and Misdemeanors,” a wise European existentialist, Professor Levy, appears on video reflecting on the difficulties of living well in a universe without God. Here is one clip: Professor Levy : We must always remember, that when we are born, we need a great deal of love, in order to persuade us to stay in life. Once we get that love, it usually lasts us. But, the universe is a pretty cold place. It's we who invest it with our feelings and, under certain conditions, we feel that the thing isn't worth it any more. What are these “certain conditions” in which we feel that life “isn’t worth it anymore”—conditions in which love dries up? How about a world in which there is no place for us, where we don’t matter, where there is nothing we can do that has value? Is this not the world in which so many people now find themselves, the world from which they flee from their lives into a stupor brought on by alcohol or opioids, or escape ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Saving the Time of Our Lives

Thinking in the wake of Martin Hägglund’s This Life: Secular Life and SpiritualFreedom If we had all the time in the world, if we were immortal, then it wouldn’t matter how we spent our time, for there would always be more of it. But if life is short, then it matters a lot. If we and the people we love are mortal and can die at any moment – and will die at some moment – then every day and every minute of our finite lives is supremely important. How, then, should we arrange our lives together so that the time of our brief lives is well spent? In view of our mortality, wouldn’t we want   to spend as much of our allotted time as possible doing things we want to do, that are worth doing for their own sake, and to minimize the time we spend doing things we have to do? There is the realm of freedom and the realm of necessity. The realm of necessity is what we have to do whether we want to or not; it includes the activities necessary for maintaining life: cleanin...
Post a Comment
Read more

An Epidemic of Despair

An Epidemic of Despair There is an epidemic of despair in the United States. The visible part is the increase in what have been called “deaths of despair” -- deaths by drugs, alcohol, and suicide. Among people who have not gone to college and for whom a traditional middle-class life is more and more out of reach, such deaths are rising steadily. The increases are connected to “a measurable deterioration in economic and social wellbeing.” [1] In a West Virginia town where textile plants and woolen mills that once provided good jobs now stand empty, a journalist who used to live there was asked why so many people there are struggling with opioids, including heroin.. He responded , “In my opinion, the desperation in [this area], and places like it, is a  social  vacancy,” he said. “People don’t feel they have a purpose.” … “Many drug addicts, he explained, are “trying to escape the reality that this place doesn’t give them anything. That’s really hard to live with...
Post a Comment
Read more